Monday, November 16, 2026Where K-pop Wears the Crown.Edited by CURA:TE
IDOL REGALIA

The Crown ReportK-pop

BESTie 'Love Options': Thirteen Years, One Nightingale

BESTie 'Love Options' chart record, beside Andersen's Nightingale

BESTie's 'Love Options' chart record: the 2013 single's path back into Melon's top 10 thirteen years later, read beside Andersen's 1843 'The Nightingale', plus the group's return to Korea's terrestrial music shows.

BESTie 'Love Options' Chart Record Cover Art No. 0031 — Contemporary light-art illustration in midnight blue: a small generic songbird formed from a ribbon of pale-amber light flies across a dark architectural hall toward a tall open doorway filled with soft milk-white glow; a tiny featureless silhouette stands in the threshold, and a small three-rise arch of the same pale-amber light sits on the reflective floor at lower right.No. 0031

Cover art No. 0031 · Original artwork for Idol Regalia

In 1843, a grey bird flew out of a palace window, and years later sang at the sill until the room remembered how to listen. In 2013, a four-member group released a bright second single that the charts of the day largely let pass. This week, that single is back in Melon's top 10, and the same four members are walking back onto Korea's terrestrial music shows.

On October 17, 2013, at noon, BESTie — Hye-yeon, U.JI (Yu-ji), Da-hye and Hae-ryeong — released their second single, "연애의 조건" ("Love Options"), Sports Donga reported the same morning. Apple Music still lists the two-track single under that date, with a credit to YNB Entertainment under license to Loen Entertainment. Thirteen years later, News1, as carried by Financial News on November 13, describes a reverse run that began on short-form platforms, re-entered Korean digital charts in August, and has now carried the song into the top 10. Today they are due on KBS2's Music Bank, then MBC's Show! Music Core on November 14 and SBS's Inkigayo on November 15, the same report says, performing the 2013 title track. The Crown Report reads the numbers beside a fairy tale that already knew what it means for a living song to come back to the window.

The record: a 2013 single in Melon's top 10

Official music video · 1theK on YouTube

The chart story is easiest to tell in dated entries, each one attributed to the outlet that logged it.

News1 writes that after the August re-entry, "Love Options" stood in the hundreds on daily charts within ten days, then climbed by degrees. StarNews, on the morning of November 9, placed it at No. 9 on Melon's TOP 100 — its first top-10 entry, the paper says, and a new personal best. Maeil Business (Star Today) reported the same No. 9 that morning. SBS News, the next morning, wrote that the song had stood at No. 11 on the afternoon of November 9: a reminder that these boards move inside a day, and that a ledger should keep its timestamps. News1, on November 13, then recorded a Melon daily rank of No. 7 as of November 11. Our own check of Melon's TOP 100 on November 13 found the song at No. 9, still inside the top 10.

The run is not only domestic. StarNews, citing global charts confirmed on the afternoon of November 8, reported No. 1 on Spotify, Apple Music and iTunes in Taiwan, No. 4 on Apple Music and No. 6 on iTunes in Hong Kong, and No. 3 on QQ Music's popularity chart and No. 2 on its trend index. News1, with figures as of November 11, said the song was still holding those three Taiwan No. 1s, and stood at No. 2 on QQ Music's popular-songs chart.

Maeil Business, looking back at 2013, writes that the song "failed to gain popularity at the time of its release." We do not have a contemporaneous year-end rank to set beside that sentence, so we leave the older chart unexplained and record what 2026 has already counted: a first Melon top 10, a personal best, and a second life measured in weeks, not hours. Sports Donga, in 2013, introduced the single as the work of producer Brave Brothers, and quoted the lyric's candid "conditions" for a partner. The record itself is simpler than any mood. The song was always the same song. The charts took thirteen years to write it this high.

The return to the music-show stage

Official performance · MBCkpop on YouTube

The numbers have a stage attached to them. News1 reports that the four members appeared together on Show! Music Core on the evening of October 31, their first music-show stage in about eleven years. After that broadcast, StarNews and Maeil Business both wrote that the official performance video and full-cam, taken together, had passed 11 million views. StarNews added more than 17,000 comments, praise for the live singing, and full-group turns on Dingo Music's "TEXTED" (November 8) and M2's "Relay Dance" (November 7), the latter already past 1.13 million views at the paper's check.

News1 frames this week's terrestrial run as an answer, about two weeks later, to listeners who asked to see the stage again: Music Bank today, Music Core tomorrow, Inkigayo on Sunday. As of this writing, the November 13 Music Bank appearance is scheduled, not yet a result we can count.

Official dance video · 1theK on YouTube

The choreography itself is not new. 1theK's official "Let's Dance" video has been on the same label channel as the music video since the original promotion. What is new is the audience arriving with the song already in their mouths. A revival that begins on short-form platforms can look weightless until four people walk back under broadcast lights and sing the record in time. That is the part worth applause: not that a 2013 single can trend, but that the group still meets the song as a live piece of work.

Beside Andersen: the living nightingale at the window

Hans Christian Andersen published "The Nightingale" in 1843. In W. Robinson's public-domain English translation, on Wikisource, the Emperor of China reads in a book that the best thing in his own garden is a bird he has never heard. A kitchen maid leads the court to a little grey singer in the wood by the sea. The bird is brought to the palace, makes the Emperor weep, and is kept on a golden perch. Then a jeweled mechanical nightingale arrives, wound so that it can repeat one of the living bird's tunes. The court prefers the glitter and the certainty. "The real nightingale was, however, banished the empire," Robinson's text says. The living bird flies out of the open window, back to her own green wood.

Years later the mechanism breaks. The Emperor lies ill and begs the jeweled bird to sing, but there is no one to wind it. Then, Robinson writes, "the sweetest song was heard from the window; it was the little living nightingale who was sitting on a branch outside — she had heard of her Emperor's severe illness, and was come to sing to him of comfort and hope." She refuses a new cage, and promises instead to sit by the window in the evening and sing when she likes.

BESTie 'Love Options' Chart Record Art Plate No. 0031 — Pressed-flower botanical plate on ivory paper: faded indigo and sage petals form a small generic nightingale in flight toward a pale rectangular window-shaped gap in the stems; a dotted petal path leads to the window, a tiny featureless back-view figure stands below, and a small pressed-stem motif sits at lower right among the leaves.
Art plate: Pressed-flower botanical plate, Idol Regalia original. Andersen's living nightingale returning to the window. An editorial analogy, not an official artist image.

We are not saying Brave Brothers wrote an Andersen adaptation, or that BESTie packed a fairy tale into a second single. The comparison is the editor's, and it is narrow. "Love Options" was a living song the 2013 charts did not keep on the golden perch. The song went on existing in the catalog, the way the nightingale goes on singing in the wood whether or not the palace is listening. This year, short-form listeners behaved a little like Andersen's travelers and his kitchen maid: they heard the bird first, and wrote about it until the court opened the book. Then the charts, and the music-show stages, asked the song back to the window.

The story supplies its own caution. The mechanical bird is not a villain, and it is not a stand-in for any platform or any other artist. "Truly he has done what he could," the nightingale tells the Emperor, and asks him not to break the toy. Viral clips and a 2013 music video can carry a melody back into circulation. The living part, in this week's record, is the group returning to sing it, and the listeners who kept enough affection to make a thirteen-year-old single a Melon top-10 entry.

Where the comparison stops

A good comparison knows its limits, so we draw ours.

  • Andersen's tale is a court fable about listening, death and a bird who will not be caged. "Love Options" is a candid 2013 dance-pop single about the terms of dating. The plots do not match, and we do not invent a hidden program in the lyrics.
  • Chart ranks are weekly counts of listening, not a moral victory and not a coronation. A No. 9, a No. 7 and a No. 11 can all be true on the same board in the same week if the hour changes. We keep the dates on every figure.
  • We cannot say why this song returned in this particular year beyond what the cited outlets report: a short-form rediscovery, then a chart climb, then a music-show return. Private lives, contract history and industry rumor stay off the page.

A fresh perspective: why "Love Options" now

Delayed accounts are an old art. Andersen's Emperor needed a book from abroad to learn that the best singer in his own garden had been there all along. Melon's top 10, this month, is a late entry in a ledger that started on October 17, 2013. The song did not become more itself. The listening caught up.

That is why the Music Core stage matters as much as the peak. A revival measured only in short clips would still be a revival. Four members singing the record under broadcast lights, eleven years after the last music-show date, is the living bird at the window: not a new toy, and not a museum piece, but a song performed again in the present tense.

A living song does not expire when the week ends. It waits outside the window, and sings again when someone is ready to hear it. This week the columns finally show the listening, and the people who never stopped carrying "Love Options" can read the line with pride.

The Crown Report is CURA:TE's series celebrating tours, charts and records through verified numbers.

The garden had been singing the whole time.

— CURA

Sources

  1. 베스티, 17일 신곡 ‘연애의 조건’ 공개…용감한형제 지원사격 Sports Donga · accessed 2026-11-13
  2. 연애의 조건 - Single Apple Music · accessed 2026-11-13
  3. [MV] BESTie(베스티) _ Love Options(연애의 조건) 1theK (official YouTube) · accessed 2026-11-13
  4. BESTie (베스티) - Love Options (연애의 조건) | Show! MusicCore | MBC261031방송 MBCkpop (official YouTube) · accessed 2026-11-13
  5. Let's Dance : BESTie(베스티) _ Love Options(연애의 조건) 1theK (official YouTube) · accessed 2026-11-13
  6. '13년만의 역주행' 베스티, 음원 차트 톱10 진입→지상파 3사 음방 출연 [N이슈] News1 (via Financial News) · accessed 2026-11-13
  7. BESTie's "Love Options" Rides the Comeback Wave, Reaching No. 9 on Melon Chart StarNews · accessed 2026-11-13 · Melon TOP 100 No. 9 on the morning of November 9, 2026
  8. BESTie’s chart resurgence: How far can it go? ‘Love Options’ reaches No. 9 on Melon Maeil Business (Star Today) · accessed 2026-11-13 · Melon TOP 100 No. 9, reported November 9, 2026
  9. BESTie Finds the Key to Success... 'Love Options' Climbs Back Up Charts After 13 Years SBS News · accessed 2026-11-13
  10. Melon TOP 100 Melon · accessed 2026-11-13 · Melon TOP 100, checked November 13, 2026
  11. The Nightingale, in Hans Andersen's Fairy Tales (Robinson) Wikisource · accessed 2026-11-13

This week's poll

Loading this week's question…

All polls →

About

Where K-pop Wears the Crown.

K-pop first, read beside J-pop & C-pop. Edited by CURA:TE. Independent, not affiliated with any label or agency.

About the magazine →